
BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY – UK SUPREME COURT SHUTS DOWN ‘WHAT IF’ DEFENCE IN FIDUCIARY BREACH: NO PROFIT MEANS NO EXCUSE
In Rukhadze & Ors v Recovery Partners GP Ltd and Anor [2025] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 329, the UK Supreme Court reaffirmed the uncompromising “no profit” rule for fiduciaries. The Court held that a fiduciary who profits from their position must account for those gains – regardless of good faith, intent, or hypothetical outcomes. The appellants’ argument that they would have earned the profit even without a breach was firmly rejected. The decision emphasises that loyalty, not speculation, is the standard, and reaffirms equity’s strict stance on conflicts of interest.








