Yew Huoi, How & Associates | Leading Malaysia Law Firm

Menu

RESHAPING HOUSING LAW: THE IMPACT OF ANG MING LEE ON DEVELOPERS AND BUYERS

Introduction

The Federal Court’s 2020 decision in Ang Ming Lee marked a pivotal moment in Malaysian housing law by declaring Regulation 11(3) of the Housing Development (Control and Licensing) Regulations 1989 (“HDR 1989”) ultra vires the parent Act. We have in our earlier article highlighted its application in this article. This ruling invalidated the Minister’s power to grant extensions of time (“EOT”) for developers, forcing them to face claims for Liquidated Ascertained Damages (“LAD”) for delays.

Immediate Impact of the Ang Ming Lee Decision

Initially, the Ang Ming Lee ruling created significant disruption in the housing industry. Developers who had relied on EOTs to delay the delivery of properties were suddenly exposed to claims for Liquidated Ascertained Damages (“LAD”) from purchasers for late delivery. The invalidation of these EOTs meant that developers could no longer escape liability for delays by relying on the extensions granted by the Controller of Housing.

Prospective vs. Retrospective Application

One of the key issues following the Ang Ming Lee decision was whether the ruling should apply retrospectively or prospectively. A retrospective application would mean that all EOTs granted under Regulation 11(3), even those granted before the Ang Ming Lee decision, would be considered invalid. This could potentially lead to an avalanche of claims against developers for LAD, significantly impacting the housing market.

Recognizing the potential chaos and injustice a retrospective application could cause, the Federal Court in Obata-Ambak Holdings Sdn Bhd v Prema Bonanza Sdn Bhd clarified that the Ang Ming Lee decision applies prospectively. This means that EOTs granted before the Ang Ming Lee decision are not retroactively invalidated. Developers and purchasers who had relied on these extensions based on the legal framework as it existed before Ang Ming Lee can rest assured that their contracts and extensions remain valid.

Court’s Role and Future Implications

Post-Ang Ming Lee, the courts have emphasized strict adherence to statutory contracts. Developers must comply with all legal requirements and timelines, as the courts are less likely to overlook failures. While the prospective application of Ang Ming Lee maintains market stability, it also reinforces the need for accountability within the industry.

Conclusion

Ang Ming Lee has reshaped the legal landscape for developers and purchasers, emphasizing the importance of statutory protections and the need for compliance. The decision, while applied prospectively, serves as a reminder of the critical role of the courts in upholding these protections and ensuring fair play in the housing market.

Reference Cases

  • Ang Ming Lee & Ors v Menteri Kesejahteraan Bandar, Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan & Anor and other appeals [2020] 1 MLJ 281; [2020] 1 CLJ 162, FC (refd)
  • CIMB Bank Bhd (formerly known as Bumiputera Commerce Bank Bhd) v Sebang Gemilang Sdn Bhd & Anor [2018] 3 MLJ 689
  • Obata-Ambak Holdings Sdn Bhd v Prema Bonanza Sdn Bhd Federal Court Civil Appeal no. 02(i)-70-08/2022 (W)

Back to Latest Legal Updates

Sorotan Terkini

NAVIGATION AND SHIPPING LAW – COLLISION REGULATIONS – COLLISION AT SEA – A WAKE-UP CALL FOR ADHERING TO NAVIGATION RULES

The collision between the FMG Sydney and MSC Apollo highlights the critical importance of adhering to established navigation rules. Deviations, delayed actions, and reliance on radio communications instead of clear, early maneuvers can lead to disastrous outcomes. This case serves as a stark reminder for mariners: follow the rules, act decisively, and prioritize safety above assumptions.

Read More »
31 Julai ,2025 Tiada Ulasan

SHIPPING AND ADMIRALTY IN REM – A SINKING ASSET – COURT ORDERS SALE OF ARRESTED VESSEL TO PRESERVE CLAIM SECURITY

In a landmark admiralty decision, the High Court ordered the pendente lite sale of the arrested vessel Shi Pu 1, emphasizing the principle of preserving claim security over the defendant’s financial incapacity. The court ruled that the vessel, deemed a “wasting asset,” could not remain under arrest indefinitely without proper maintenance or security. This case reinforces the necessity for shipowners to manage arrested assets proactively to prevent significant financial and legal repercussions.

Read More »
31 Julai ,2025 Tiada Ulasan

EMPLOYMENT LAW – IS DIRECTOR A DIRECTOR OR EMPLOYEE? UNPACKING DUAL ROLES IN EMPLOYMENT LAW

The Court of Appeal clarified the dual roles of directors as both shareholders and employees, affirming that executive directors can qualify as “workmen” under the Industrial Relations Act 1967. The decision emphasizes that removal as a director does not equate to lawful dismissal as an employee unless due process is followed. This case highlights the importance of distinguishing shareholder rights from employment protections, ensuring companies navigate such disputes with clarity and fairness.

Read More »
31 Julai ,2025 Tiada Ulasan

REGULATIONS – GENERAL AGREEMENT ON TARIFFS AND TRADE (GATT 1947 ) – ARTICLE I

This legal update explores key provisions of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT 1947), focusing on Article I (Most-Favoured-Nation Treatment), Article II (Schedules of Concessions), Article XX (General Exceptions), and Article XXI (Security Exceptions). Article I mandates that any trade advantage granted by one contracting party to another must be extended unconditionally to all other parties. Article II ensures that imported goods from contracting parties receive treatment no less favourable than that outlined in agreed schedules, while also regulating permissible taxes and charges. Articles XX and XXI provide exceptions for measures necessary to protect public morals, health, security interests, and compliance with domestic laws. The provisions reflect the foundational principles of non-discrimination, transparency, and fair trade, while allowing for limited, well-defined exceptions. This summary is intended to provide a concise reference for businesses and legal practitioners involved in international trade law.

Read More »
3 April ,2025 Tiada Ulasan
ms_MYMY
en_USEN zh_TWZH ms_MYMY
× Hubungi Kami