ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – RULES OF NATURAL JUSTICE – RIGHT TO BE HEARD

What is administrative law in general? 

  •  Administrative law is a large field of law that deals with the agencies that are in charge of a variety of government projects. Administrative law governs agencies, commissions, and boards. Administrative law is frequently encountered by the public in the context of a public benefit that has been refused or terminated.

 When can natural justice be claimed?

  • .In judicial, quasi-judicial, and administrative systems, two norms have evolved over time to embody natural justice principles: 1) ‘Nemo debet esse judex in propria causa,’ which states that no one should be judged in his own cause, and 2) ‘audi alteram partem,’ which states that no one should be condemned without first hearing their side of story. 

Q. In the recent case of Nurul Rifayah bt Muhammad Iqbal & Ors v Tan Sri Dato’ Hj Mahiaddin bin Md Yassin & Ors [2021] 12 MLJ 510 the voting rights has been reduced from 21 to 18 years old and will be taken effect starting from July 2021. However, it has been delayed till September 1, 2022 due to the Movement Control Order. This has affected the youth in Malaysia as the Malaysian youth organisation (UNDI 18) has been fighting for these issues. Does this sound fair to you? 

A. If you were in this position, the best way to deal with it is to request the court for a judicial review regarding the issue faced by you. However, there are a few steps that the court will look into before granting  judicial review. This will avoid frivolous or vexatious claims made by the appellant. Hence, O 53 r 2(4) of the Rules of Court 2012 will be read by the court during the two stage test to request leave from the court. Once the court sees nothing wrong with proceeding on the judicial review, leave will be granted. 

What are the remedies available for judicial review? 

  •  Habeas corpus, certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus are examples of public law remedies. In Malaysia, habeas corpus is a well-known prerogative writ that is frequently used to challenge the validity of an ISA detention decision. Regardless of nationality, anybody or someone acting on their behalf can appeal such a writ. In general, a writ of habeas corpus will be issued if the applicant can show that the custody is illegal and that the process of bringing the prisoner to trial is taking too long. It should be remembered that one must appear before a magistrate within 24 hours of being detained.
  •  Certiorari, which means “quashing order,” is a retroactive order that brings a decision made by the authority before the court and asks that it be overturned. Prohibition, on the other hand, is a future command to overturn a decision that is about to be made. It is important to remember that failing to comply with such an order constitutes criminal contempt of court. Meanwhile, mandamus is used to compel the decision–making body to undertake public tasks that it has failed to do. It is enforced to guarantee that public officials carry out their responsibilities. Both certiorari and mandamus can be sought concurrently.

Recent Post

DISTRIBUTION OF ASSETS – LEGAL RIGHTS OF CHILDREN BORN IN UNREGISTERED CUSTOMARY MARRIAGES TO INHERIT INTESTATE ESTATES

Born to parents in an unregistered Chinese customary marriage, an individual was deemed illegitimate following their father’s intestate death. The key legal issue is whether this individual can inherit under the Distribution Act 1958 (DA). The DA does not restrict inheritance to legitimate children only; it includes all bloodline descendants. Therefore, the individual qualifies as ‘issue’ and is entitled to inherit their father’s estate despite questions of legitimacy.

Read More »

FAMILY LAW – ANALYZING THE EFFICIENCY OF DIVORCE PROCEEDINGS IN CASES OF ADULTERY WITHOUT CLAIMS FOR DAMAGES

A husband filed for divorce due to living apart from his wife for two years, while the wife attributed the breakdown to adultery, involving the alleged adulteress without seeking damages. This raises questions about the necessity of addressing adultery in divorce when no compensation is sought, as Section 54 of the Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976 emphasizes irretrievable breakdown without fault.

Read More »

ROAD TRAFFIC – DUTY OF DIRECTOR GENERAL OF ROAD TRANSPORT

In a legal spotlight, X’s acquisition of a cloned vehicle unknowingly, due to lapses in the Road Transport Department’s record-keeping, raises questions about statutory duties and public trust. The case underscores the importance of stringent vehicle registry maintenance to prevent ownership of unlawfully modified vehicles.

Read More »

INDUSTRIAL LAW – NAVIGATING THE LEGALITIES OF RETRENCHMENT

The dismissal of X by Company ABC, citing economic downturns, presents a compelling case on the complexities of employment termination and retrenchment legality. X contested his redundancy, claiming his role in property management and services was unaffected by the property development market’s challenges. This case probes into the legitimacy of retrenchment under economic duress and the employer’s duty to act in good faith, as guided by Section 20(3) of the Industrial Relations Act 1967. The burden rests on Company ABC to prove the necessity and genuineness of X’s redundancy, with failure to do so possibly leading to a verdict of unjustified termination. This scenario underscores the critical importance of evidence and intention in retrenchment cases, as reflected in precedents like Akilan a/l Subramanian v. Prima Awam (M) Sdn Bhd.

Read More »

PROPERTY LAW – LEGAL IMPLICATIONS OF SALE AND PURCHASE AGREEMENT BREACHES AND THE RIGHT TO OFFSET IN MALAYSIAN PROPERTY TRANSACTIONS

In the realm of Malaysian property transactions, the intricacies of Sale and Purchase Agreements (SPAs) and the enforcement of Liquidated Ascertained Damages (LAD) play pivotal roles in safeguarding the interests of both developers and purchasers. This article delves into the legal framework governing the rights and obligations of parties involved in property transactions, particularly focusing on the consequences of contractual breaches and the conditions under which a purchaser can exercise the right to offset against LAD. Through the examination of relevant case law and statutory provisions, we illuminate the legal pathways available for resolving disputes arising from the failure to adhere to the terms of SPAs, thereby offering insights into the equitable administration of justice in the context of Malaysian property law.

Read More »

WINDING-UP – OFFICIAL RECEIVER AND LIQUIDATOR (“ORL”)

In cases of compulsory winding up, the court would appoint a liquidator under s.478 of the Companies Act 2016 (“CA 2016”) to expeditiously recover and realise the assets of the wound-up company for the distribution of dividends to creditors and administer any outstanding matters involving………..

Read More »
en_USEnglish
× How can I help you?